Login

favour of or against the topic "Lord Ullin's daughter was right in her decision to defy her father." Give logical and relevant reasons, i m confused can any one give me right suggesion plzzzzzzzzzzzzz fastt

"Lord Ullin’s daughter was not right in her decision to defy her father" 
The following points might help you to frame your debate: 
Against the motion 
(i) As Lord Ullin’s daughter was not matured enough to judge the right person to whom she could get married. She was not right in her decision to defy her father. 
(ii) Lord Ullin was upholding the convention of the Scottish society in not giving consent to his daughter’s marriage with the Chieftain. According to the convention, the father of a daughter would chose the bridegroom so that there was no error in judgement. 
(iii) Lord Ullin’s daughter should not have defied her father as her father was anticipating something wrong to happen. 
  • 5
View Full Answer

any one alse

  • -3

She was absolutely right in her decision..is her father there to guide her before eloping? .No, he was always trying to shout at her. never tried to hear her problems.He was proud and couldn't beleive the act that his daughter loved the man who was much below his rank.Then what she could do. her lover knew that his life is also in danger but he didnt abandon her ..he tried to make her happy..so with whom she should stay? think of it!

Was lord ullin's daughter was right in her decision to defy her father?
No , she was not right as she didn't thought of her father and when she was drowning she just moved her hands towards her father for help.

  • 13

 She was passionately in luv wth the chieftain so it was not possible 4 her to leave him and reurn to her father.his father was more concerned about his status than his only daughter......so ithink she was perfectly right in her decision....

  • 0

any perfect debate is here or not

  • 0

as parents is always right,lord unill is also right.lord unill grew him,make him to take decision,he guide him what is or what is wrong and lord unill's daughter is done very wrong with him.

  • -3

she was wrong

  • 2

because as parent look after us from our birth we should listen to them but she didn't listen and thought of eloping .she cheated her fathers feeling . she was in favour of the new guy who entered in her life just few years ago but not in favour of her father. real lovers are those who stand and proove them not those who run away from the problems. so i think she was not right in her decision

  • 0
she was right because she knew what was best for her and because it was her life and it was her decision
  • 4
Against Lord ullins dauhuter
 
  • 2
This answer will depend on the way you think about this situation. According to me the daughter was correct in her approach because it solely depends on her whom she'll marry. Lord Ullin does not approve of her love affair as the society does not accept a girl who marries against her father's wish. This left her and the chieftain with no other option but to elope and keep their love alive but their unity was short lived due to the fierce storm which consumed the lovers along with the courageous Boatman.
  • -1
she was right in her decision
  • 2
What are you looking for?