Thisdiscussion was taking place in a class Read the various argumentsand state which of these do you agree with - Pol Science - The Philosophy of Constitution

Question

Thisdiscussion was taking place in a class Read the
various argumentsand state which of these do you agree with and
why
Jayesh:I still think that our Constitution is only a
borrowed document
Saba:Do you mean to say that there is nothing Indian in
it? But is theresuch a thing as Indian and western in the case of
values and ideas?Take equality between men and women What is
western about it? Andeven if it is, should we reject it only
because it is western?
Jayesh:What I mean is that after fighting for independence
from the British,did we not adopt their system of parliamentary
government?
Neha:You forget that when we fought the British, we were
not against theBritish as such, we were against the principle of
colonialism Thathas nothing to do with adopting a system of
government that wewanted, wherever it came from

Global Expert · Accepted Answer

Anyanswer supported with argument or explanation would
solve thepurpose It is strongly recommended that you prepare
thesolution on your own However, one sample solution has
beenprovided for your reference:
Thearguments of Saba and Neha are correct that the idea of
equalitycannot be rejected merely because it is of western origin
The valuesthat are a part of the Constitution are universal and
thus, cannot bediscriminated as Indian or Western It is also
correct that while theBritish were unjust in their policy of
colonialism, there werecertain principles of their governance that
were modern and suitableas they allowed people to choose their own
representatives Thus, thepositive values of British system should
not be ignored on the basisof negative impact of British
colonialism