A = {1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12}
R = {(a,b) : Ia-bI = 4x, where x belongs to Whole numbers}
.
For every 'a' belonging to A, (a,a) belongs to R, as Ia-aI = 0, which is 4(0), hence is a multiple of 4. Therefore R is reflexive.
.
If (a,b) belongs to R, I(a-b)I = 4x, and also, I(b-a)I = 4x. Hence (b,a) also belongs to R, and therefore, R is symmetric.
.
If (a,b) and (b,c) belongs to R, then I(a-b)I I(b-c)I is a multiple of 4.
Hence, (a-b) = 4x and (b-c) = 4y, where x and y belongs to Integers.[here its integers because when modulus is removed, the RHS can be +/- 4x. hence we can say so].
therefore, (a-b) + (b-c) = 4x + 4y = 4(x+y)
a-b + b- c = multiple of 4,
Hence, a-c = multiple of 4.
Therefore, (a,c) belongs to R and R is Transitive.
.
Hence R is reflexive, symmetric and transitive and so, R is said to be an equivalence Relation.
.
The set of elements related to 1 in R such that I(k-1)I is a multiple of 4, where k belongs to A is:-
I(1-1)I = 0, which is 4(0) and hence is a multiple of 4.
I(5-1)I = 4, which is 4(1) and hence is a multiple of 4.
I(9-1)I = 8,which is 4(2) and hence is a multiple of 4.
.
beyond 9, we hav I(13-1)I = 12 = 4(3), but then 13 does not belong to A.
Hence the set of elements in A, related to 1 by R, is {1,5,9}.
.